Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker Review

Are you a big fan of ice-cream? Of course, you are – we all love it! But what if I said that you don’t have to buy it at a local store? That’s right: with the right equipment, it’s very well possible to make incredibly tasty ice-cream without even leaving home. So, in this post, I’ll be your guide in the search for the Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker. These machines aren’t particularly cheap, but they do carry excellent value.

After carefully testing a long list of machines, I picked the following three. They have a perfect price-quality balance and will be money well spent. Take a good look at the comparison table first to learn of their best features, and only then move on to the detailed reviews. Let’s fulfill our childhood dreams and make some ice-cream!

Comparison Table – Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker (Updated October, 2020)

Product Product Information View on Amazon
Editor’s Choice

PREMIUM 6 qt. - Immergood Stainless Steel Ice Cream Maker - Hand Crank

1) PREMIUM

  • Best Features:
    – Leak-free, rust-proof, and insulated
    – Won’t take long to take apart
    – Sturdy construction; can take a beating
  • Size: 6 qt
  • Available Options:
    4 qt
    8 qt

Check Price

Elite Gourmet EIM-506 6 quart Old-Fashioned Ice Cream Maker with electric motor and hand crank

2) Maxi-Matic

  • Best Features:
    – Easy to switch between electric and manual operations
    – Includes over-heating protection for the motor
    – Hand-crafted pinewood bucket
  • Size: 6 qt

Check Price

6 qt Country Ice Cream Maker - Classic Wooden Tub - Hand Crank

3) Country Freezer

  • Best Features:
    – High-quality white oak tub
    – Very easy to clean
    – Designed, made, and tested in the USA
  • Size: 6 qt
  • Available Options:
    4 qt
    8 qt
    20 qt

Check Price

Best Hand Crank Ice Cream Maker Review

1. Ice Cream Maker with Hand Crank by PREMIUM

This machine looks like a metallic bucket, and while some folks like the old-school design, others find it a bit too “boxy”. But that’s pretty much the only con. As for the pros, I’d like to mention the sturdy (stainless steel) construction. The PREMIUM ice-cream maker is very durable and reliable. On top of that, its well-protected against leaks and rust (and highly insulated).

The triple-layer design (poly on both sides, and insulation in the middle) is even more reason to consider purchasing this wonderful machine. This is a one-piece tub, and it’s very easy to take out all the separate parts (the dasher, the can, and the crank) to clean them. The price-tag isn’t particularly steep, either. And one more thing: the company backs its product by a generous 3-year warranty, meaning you can always expect to get a replacement.

Product Rating
Easy to Clean
5
Flavor
5
Easy to Use
5
Result
5
Pros and Cons
Protected against rust and leaks, highly insulated
Can be taken apart in less than a minute
Sturdy stainless steel construction
Some people might not like the old-school metallic design

General Impression
Stephen James
Stephen James
Ask Question

Built to last – that’s the best way to describe this machine. It is well-protected against rust and leaks and will serve you for a very long time. The retro “bath-tub” design might be a bit of a turn-off, but that’s well-compensated by the affordable price-tag and the three-year warranty by PREMIUM.

View On Amazon

2. Ice Cream Maker with Motor & Hand Crank by Maxi-Matic

If you’re not sure you can handle the manual cranking, take a closer look at this Maxi-Matic ice-cream maker. Along with the traditional handle for manual operation, it also comes packed with a powerful motor (3500rpm, high torque). That motor, in turn, is protected against overheating and is quite effective at making tasty stuff. It can product six quarts of frozen yogurt, gelato, and, of course, ice-cream.

Still, if you need firmer ice, I’d recommend using your hands to crank it manually. The freezer canister can make fresh ice-cream in less than 40 minutes, which is an average result for this price range. The tub, in turn, is hand-crafted from pinewood and looks pretty great in any environment. Sadly, the company doesn’t provide any type of warranty (in contrast to the other two products on today’s list).

Product Rating
Easy to Clean
4.9
Flavor
4.8
Easy to Use
4.9
Result
4.9
Pros and Cons
Can be operated manually or with an electric motor
The motor is protected against overheating
Hand-crafted from high-quality pinewood
The machine isn’t backed by any type of warranty

General Impression
Stephen James
Stephen James
Ask Question

If you’ve been searching for an ice-cream maker that comes with a crank handle and an electric motor, this machine might deserve your attention. It does an excellent job of making and freezing ice-cream (and other sweet stuff), and won’t take much space on the kitchen counter. Strangely enough, there’s no warranty backing it up, but that’s not a very big con.

View On Amazon

1. Ice Cream Maker with Hand Crank by Country Freezer

The third “contestant” isn’t one of those low-budget machines – Country Freezer made a bet on premium-level materials and construction, not affordability. The tub looks amazing, thanks to the beautiful combination of white oak and stainless steel. The rustproof bronze housing and zinc gears don’t rust or get corroded over time. This is a 100% US-made product and is shipped to any of the 50 states in short order.

The can is extra heavy and is made of high-quality stainless steel. The entire construction is very easy to clean and to keep in good shape. Replacement parts are available in most stores or can be ordered online. Country Freezer provides a one-year general warranty along with a five-year warranty on all the steel parts. It’s also worth mentioning that it doesn’t take a lot of strength to crank the ice and even your kids will be able to handle that.

Product Rating
Easy to Clean
4.9
Flavor
4.9
Easy to Use
4.8
Result
4.9
Pros and Cons
Premium-quality white oak tub
Easy to clean and to maintain
A US-made product
A bit on the expensive side

General Impression
Stephen James
Stephen James
Ask Question

This ice-cream maker looks good, doesn’t take long to make ice-cream (up to 25 minutes), and is very easy to clean. It’s a US-made product with a generous warranty. The price-tag isn’t particularly cheap, but if you’ve got some extra bucks to spare, it will be a reasonable purchase, especially in the long run.

View On Amazon

Conclusion

Well, there you have it: my list of the finest ice-cream makers on the market. These machines are very easy to use, work flawlessly, and look good in any environment. The high quality of the materials (and the impressive crafting) makes them an even more attractive purchase. If you’re not ready to buy a particularly expensive product, PREMIUM might have a good offer for you.

Its ice-cream maker is well-protected against rust and leaks, made to last, and backed by a generous warranty. With Maxi-Matic, you’ll get the best of the two worlds: that machine can be operated manually or do all the heavy lifting with the built-in motor. As for Country Freezer, this company is all about style and grace. Plus, the tub and the can are very easy to clean. So, choose wisely!

Stephen James
Stephen James

Hello! My name is Stephen James, and I am a home-improvement fanatic! It is amazing how many interesting items there are that can make your home a lot safer and comfortable. What I do is seek for all the innovative inventions that each and every one of you can easily introduce into your house. Every item that I see fit to be reviewed and incorporated into your home is carefully picked and then tested by me. My primary goal is to help you fix any possible issue in the household with the best fitting solutions. If you want to know some more about my daily activities, you can follow me on Twitter - https://twitter.com/stephenjamespro

Rate author
Household Professor
Leave a Reply